File Name: time is a waste of time and money caroline bird .zip
Caroline Bird make higher education for all look financially prohibitive, particularly now when colleges are A great majority of our nine million college squeezed by the pressures of inflation and a students are not in school because they want to drop-off in their traditional market.
They are there Predictable demography has caught up because it has become the thing to do or because with the university empire builders. To keep like; because Mother wanted them to go, or their mammoth plants financially solvent, many some other reason entirely irrelevant to the institutions have begun to use hard-sell, Madi- course of studies for which college is supposedly son-Avenue techniques to attract students. For the rest, college is at best a so- for college administrators.
But when students rebel- school graduates grew out of a noble American ling against the Vietnam War and the draft dis- ideal. Just as the United States was the first na- covered they could disrupt a campus com- tion to aspire to teach every small child to read pletely, administrators had to act on some stu- and write, so, during the s, we became the dent complaints.
Few understood that the pro- first and only great nation to aspire to higher tests had tapped the basic discontent with col- education for all. And adults—parents, Today students protest individually employers, high school counselors—began to rather than in concert.
They drop education. Some refuse to go to college at payers footing more than half the bill. By , all. Most, of course, have neither the funds nor colleges and universities were spending more the self-confidence for constructive articulation than 30 billion dollars annually.
But still only of their discontent. They simply hang around half our high school graduates were going on. According to estimates made by the economist All across the country, I have been Fritz Machlup, if we had been educating every overwhelmed by the prevailing sadness on young person until age 22 in that year of , American campuses.
Too many young people the bill for higher education would have reached speak little, and then only in drowned voices. It is better than the place is in college. During the ful way to get away from home and become Vietnam War some ascribed the sadness to the independent without losing the financial sup- draft; now others are blaming affluence, or say it port of their parents.
And sometimes it is the has something to do with permissive upbringing. The conserva- economic analyses, the historical record, the tive Carnegie Commission estimates from 5 to opinions of the especially knowledgeable, con- 30 percent. Sol Linowitz, who was once versations with parents, professors, college ad- chairman of a special education committee on ministrators, and employers, all of whom spoke campus tension of the American Council on as alumni too.
Some- the years as productively as they otherwise where between the nursery and the employment could. No one Older alumni will identify with Richard has anything in particular against them. But fewer s, and there is no room for so many newly students each year feel this way. Daniel minted year-olds. So we temporarily get Yankelovich has surveyed undergraduate atti- them out of the way by sending them to college tudes for a number of years, and reported in where in fact only a few belong.
Some, of course, Leon Lefkowitz, chairman of the department of learn to like it, but most wind up preferring social studies at Central High School in Valley green peas. Stream, New York, interviewed college Educators admit as much.
I listened to a Mount bread. But if making be a reason for not going. The implication is money is the only goal, college is the dumbest that an year-old is too young and confused to investment you can make. I say this because a know what he wants to do, and that he should young banker in Poughkeepsie, New York, listen to those who know best and go to college. Stephen G. I believe that college has college as an investment with other investments to be judged not on what other people think is available in and college did not come out good for students, but on how it feels to the stu- on top.
At worst, it is unconsciously elitist. For instance, a Princeton-bound-high intellectual mode natural only to a few. It vio- school graduate of who liked fooling lates the fundamental egalitarian principle of re- around with cars could have banked his spect for the differences between people.
They send their chil- age high-school graduate. If successful in business, he could more reached that comfortable bracket without expect to make more than the average college the benefit of a college education. Jencks says graduate. And if he had the brains to get into that financial success in the U. In , them rich. And few parents are sophisticated when jobs were easy to get, Daniel enough to understand that in financial returns Yankelovich made his first nationwide survey alone, their children would be better off with the of students.
Sixty-five percent of them said money than with the education. The young are not alone. American to- Quite aside from the noneconomic benefits of day are all looking less to the pay of a job than college, and these should loom larger once the to the work itself. College may simply attract people who what it is to make a dollar. He worked with his are slated to earn more money anyway; those father in the family plumbing business, on the with higher IQs, better family backgrounds, a line at Chevrolet, and in the Chrysler foundry.
No one high-status families have higher incomes than works for money alone. During the most affluent years of the late In the s, some of the more practical s and s college students told their professors began to see that jobs for graduates placement officers that they wanted to be re- meant jobs for professors too. The press welcomed the change as The psychic income of these and other a return to the ethic of achievement and service.
According to one study, 93 percent of make the world better by healing the sick as urban university professors would choose the physicians or righting individual wrongs as same vocation again if they had the chance, lawyers.
Even though the monetary gap be- fessions either. The American Enterprise In- tween college professor and auto worker is now stitute estimated in that there would be surprisingly small, the difference in psychic in- more than the target ratio of doctors for come is enormous.
And the odds are little better for would- jobs of these kinds are hard to come by, even for be lawyers. Law schools are already graduat- qualified applicants, and they rarely accept the ing twice as many new lawyers every year as responsibility of helping students choose a ca- the Department of Labor thinks will be needed, reer that will lead to a job. When a young per- and the oversupply is growing every year.
The Depart- is necessary for success. Teachers, engineers ment of Labor, for instance, estimates there will and others I talked to said they find that on the be 4, new jobs for psychologists in job they rarely use what they learned in school. Whatever college graduates different fields. Charles Lawrence, a communica- Michigan State University, accuses the academic tions major in college and now the producer of community of outright hypocrisy.
I learned expect it If we care what happens to students my job doing it. Fortunately, students while they are there. A liberal-arts education is supposed to indirectly related to the campus. The sheer size of undergraduate cam- The analogy is apt. The fact is, of puses of the s makes college even less course, that the liberal arts are a religion in every stimulating now than it was 10 years ago.
To- sense of that term. When people talk about day, even motivated students are disappointed them, their language becomes elevated, meta- with their college courses and professors. Finally, a college diploma no longer And faith in personal salvation by the liberal arts opens as many vocational doors. Employers is professed in a creed intoned on ceremonial are beginning to realize that when they pay ex- occasions such as commencements. The fact is that professors are its priests.
But disseminating most of the work for which employers now ex- ideas in a four year college curriculum is slow pect college training is now or has been done in and most expensive. If you want to learn about the past by people without higher educations. Milton, Camus, or even Margaret Mead you can College, then, may be a good place for find them in paperback books, the public library, those few young people who are really drawn and even on television.
And when most people to academic work, who would rather read than talk about the value of a college education, they eat, but it has become too expensive, in money, arc not talking about great books. When at Har- time, and intellectual effort to serve as a hold- vard commencement, the president welcomes ing pen for large numbers of our young.
V Glenn Bassett, a personnel specialist at G. In most, however, it is a ticket of admission. The most charitable conclusion we can reach is that college probably has very little, if any, effect on people and things. Open navigation menu. Close suggestions Search Search. User Settings. Skip carousel. Carousel Previous. Carousel Next. What is Scribd? Uploaded by Edward Elric. Document Information click to expand document information Date uploaded Jan 13, Did you find this document useful?
Is this content inappropriate? Report this Document. Flag for inappropriate content. Download now. For Later. Related titles. Carousel Previous Carousel Next. Jump to Page. Search inside document.
In recent decades, the approach to the higher education in America has significantly changed. Students are put in the conditions of a tremendous demand for high level of knowledge and expertise in the American society, and they do everything possible to achieve the best grades in the educational evaluation. It will permit them to find better jobs and provide them with better opportunities. It is an interesting fact that in the s people had another approach to the education. The three authors provide their views on the education issue from different timeline perspectives. The middle of the 20th century was a time when American society began to foster the need to reform the system of higher education.
She argues that most students are unhappy and unsatisfied with attending college. She believes that they go to college because it has become the thing to do or because of getting pressure from their parents or societies. Furthermore, she thinks that college is not a good financial investment because career financial success depends on other factors. She believes that people gain true knowledge and skill while working in real jobs and not in college. Bird believes that college has to be judged not by what other people think is good for the students, but how good it feels to the students themselves. To some college may be a reason to avoid adult responsibilities, gain independence or avoid intolerable home situations, but to others college is an institution offering higher levels of educational purpose that will help them succeed in their careers later on with multiple benefits. College can be financially expensive.
Are advantages over his love money back guarantee that have been ruined by f. Tidy and make money. Atms dispense more important to give the state argumentative essay. September 27, this dream?
This text strives to convince students, parents, and advisors that obtaining a degree might not be in the best interest for those involved. Circling around the idea that college is requirement and no. She states that many college students are in college not because they want to but because they have to. Circling around the idea that college is a requirement and no.
The question that goes around is, does college cost too much? Well college is what an individual makes of it and depending on the circumstances, it can be worth it, but, can also not be.
In defense from the opposing side, in some cases college actually steps up to its role and establishes the worth known by most Americans. College does become the training ground for most successful careers. The injustice that is being argued through this, is the select few graduates who do have to face the trouble of not being able to obtain a job and pay off their debt. Higher education should not be a topic that costs. Having such education that cost so much only will apply to the select people who can afford the expenses.
Caroline Bird Mahoney — was an American feminist author. Born on April 15, , in New York City , Caroline Bird became the youngest member of the Vassar College class of at the age of 16, but left after her junior year to marry; she later earned a Bachelor of Arts degree at the University of Toledo and a Master of Arts degree in comparative literature at the University of Wisconsin. Years later when Sofia Montenegro , an award-winning Nicaraguan journalist and prominent feminist activist, was asked how she became a revolutionary, she said that she would never forget the book that had changed her life; she was 16 years old when she read Born Female: the High Cost of Keeping Women Down. Sexism is judging people by their sex when sex doesn't matter. Sexism is intended to rhyme with racism. Women are sexists as often as men.
Caroline Bird make higher education for all look financially prohibitive, particularly now when colleges are A great majority of our nine million college squeezed by the pressures of inflation and a students are not in school because they want to drop-off in their traditional market. They are there Predictable demography has caught up because it has become the thing to do or because with the university empire builders. To keep like; because Mother wanted them to go, or their mammoth plants financially solvent, many some other reason entirely irrelevant to the institutions have begun to use hard-sell, Madi- course of studies for which college is supposedly son-Avenue techniques to attract students. For the rest, college is at best a so- for college administrators.